  
        
        
         
        
        
        
      
        
      
        
      
       
     | 
    
      
        
       
      
       
      Policy contribution 
      
      
         
          |  
             Contribution to key objectives 
           | 
             | 
             | 
             | 
             | 
         
         
          |  
             Objective 
           | 
           
             Nuremberg 
           | 
           
             Danish Project 
           | 
           
             San Diego 
           | 
           
             UK Towns 
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
         
         
          |  
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
       
       
      
         
          |  
             Contribution to alleviation of key problems 
               
           | 
             | 
             | 
             | 
             | 
         
         
          |  
             Problem 
           | 
           
             Nuremberg 
           | 
           
             Danish Project 
           | 
           
             San Diego 
           | 
           
             UK Towns 
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Congestion-related delay 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Congestion-related unreliability 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Community severance  
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Visual intrusion 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Lack of amenity 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Global warming 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Local air pollution 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Noise  
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Reduction of green space  
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Damage to environmentally sensitive sites 
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Poor accessibility for those without a car and those 
              with mobility impairments  
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Disproportionate disadvantaging of particular social 
              or geographic groups  
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Number, severity and risk of accidents  
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Suppression of the potential for economic activity 
              in the area  
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
               
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
           
             - 
           | 
         
       
       
      Appropriate contexts 
      Traffic calming originally was developed for local residential areas, 
        but these measures have been extended to shopping areas, village centres, 
        school entrances and other sensitive locations The 1980’s saw the first 
        attempts to introduce traffic calming measures on main urban roads, mostly 
        at places where shopping and commercial activity was concentrated. The 
        creation of effective schemes is usually more difficult in such locations 
        than in residential areas because of the greater intensity of pedestrian 
        and other activity, and thus greater competition for the available space 
        (Pharaoh and Russell, 1991). 
      Hass-Klau et al (1992) surveyed 385 traffic calming schemes in UK. They 
        summarised the type of area (as defined by the local authority) as follows. 
        Traffic calming was most commonly applied to minor roads in suburban residential 
        areas (34% of all schemes) whereas only 14% were on main roads in the 
        same type of area. 15% were implemented on minor roads in inner city residential 
        areas. A small proportion (6%) was carried out on other inner city roads, 
        especially shopping streets. 29% were either in other areas or not identified. 
        Most of the schemes (88%) comprised only a small number of streets, usually 
        only one street, and few were installed or planned on an area-wide basis 
        (12%).  
      
         
          |  
             Appropriate area-types 
           | 
           
             Suitability 
           | 
         
         
          |  
             City centre 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Dense inner suburb 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Medium density suburb 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Less dense outer suburb 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             District centre 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Corridor 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Small town 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
         
          |  
             Tourist town 
           | 
           
               
           | 
         
       
       
      Adverse side-effects 
      Some traffic calming measures reduce accessibility in the area. However, 
        by making routes through the areas slower, they can also induce re-routing 
        to major roads, and hence a relocation of environmental impact.  
      A widespread problem exists between traffic calming the need of ambulances, 
        fire appliances and buses. These need to be addressed well before consultations 
        take place on individual traffic calming projects (County Surveyors Society, 
        1994). 
        
       
      Text edited at the Institute for Transport Studies, 
        University of Leeds, Leeds LS2 9JT 
          
      
        
        
       |